top of page

Buying a Business Asset or Leasing It? The Comparison That Really Matters

8 minutes ago
6 min read

A business intending to acquire a new capital asset may pay for it out of its own funds, purchase it by means of a bank loan, or enter into a finance lease agreement, under which a leasing company purchases the asset chosen by the business and grants it the use of that asset in return for periodic lease payments, together with the option to purchase it at the end of the term at a predetermined price. The three solutions differ in the timing with which the cost of the asset reduces the tax burden, in the overall cost of the transaction and in their impact on the company's liquidity, and the choice should stem from an overall assessment of these aspects. The following considerations concern movable capital assets, since real estate and cars are subject to specific rules.


The tax perspective: the timing of the deduction

From a tax perspective, the main difference lies in the timing with which the cost of the asset contributes to reducing taxable income. In the case of a purchase, whether with own funds or financed, the cost is deducted through depreciation, allocated according to the ministerial rates set for each category of assets and halved in the first financial year: a machine with a 20% rate, for example, is deducted over six financial years, with 10% in the first, 20% in each of the following four and the remaining 10% in the last. For high-technology assets, moreover, the hyper-depreciation introduced by the 2026 Budget Law allows, for investments made by 30 September 2028, the cost deductible for income tax purposes to be increased by up to 180%, providing an additional tax saving that does not merely bring the deduction forward but increases its amount.

Under a lease, by contrast, the lease payments are deductible over a period of not less than half of the depreciation period, and therefore over three years for the same machine. This period applies regardless of the term of the contract, so that, if the latter is shorter, the excess portion of the lease payments is deducted in subsequent financial years. Compared with a financed purchase, therefore, leasing does not increase the overall tax saving but brings it forward, with an appreciable benefit for liquidity in the early financial years. Hyper-depreciation is also available for assets acquired under a finance lease, but not for rented assets, and in that case the increase follows the shorter deduction period applicable to lease payments.

The advantage of leasing must, however, be assessed in light of the company's financial position. Each lease payment comprises a capital portion, which repays the cost of the asset, and an interest portion, which is subject to the same rules as interest on any loan: for corporations, interest expense is deductible up to the amount of interest income and, for the excess, within the limit of 30% of the gross operating margin from core business activities, while the amount not deducted is carried forward to subsequent financial years. A company that already carries significant debt might therefore be unable to deduct the lease interest immediately, just as with the interest on a new loan, a limit that does not affect a purchase with own funds; moreover, the interest portion is not deductible for IRAP purposes. Expected profitability must also be considered since, where losses are incurred, bringing the deduction forward generates no immediate saving but increases the tax loss, which may be carried forward to subsequent financial years within certain limits. Finally, as regards VAT, for a business that deducts it in full the difference is purely financial since, in the case of a purchase, the tax on the entire price is paid upfront to the supplier, whereas under a lease it is paid and recovered on each lease payment.


The economic and financial perspective: cost, liquidity and risks

From an economic perspective, both a loan and a lease entail a cost higher than the price of the asset on account of interest, which in the case of a lease is included in the lease payments. The comparison between different offers cannot therefore be based on the amount of the instalment, but must take into account all outlays: the initial lump-sum payment, lease payments, purchase option price and ancillary charges for the lease; instalments and arrangement fees for the loan. If the terms applied were equivalent, the two solutions would have a similar overall cost; in practice, however, leasing often proves more expensive, both because of an implicit rate that is at times higher than that of bank loans and because of the ancillary charges that accompany it, such as arrangement and contract management fees, insurance of the asset and the costs of exercising the purchase option. For both solutions, moreover, small and medium-sized enterprises can reduce the cost of interest by using the Nuova Sabatini scheme, refinanced by the 2026 Budget Law for the two-year period 2026-2027, which grants a public contribution commensurate with the interest on bank loans and leases for the purchase of new capital assets, provided that they are granted by banks or leasing companies participating in the scheme. A purchase with own funds is instead the least expensive option, provided that the liquidity used is not needed for operations. From a financial perspective, in fact, a purchase with own funds entails the immediate outlay of the entire price and may cause liquidity strains if, in the following months, unexpected payments arise or collections slow down, whereas a loan and a lease spread the outlay over time, although a lease normally provides for an initial lump-sum payment which, if large, significantly reduces its advantage.

Financed solutions also carry specific risks. A lease constitutes a binding commitment, since the lease payments remain due for the entire term of the contract even if the asset breaks down, becomes obsolete or is no longer used, and early termination is generally costly. In the event of default, the leasing company may terminate the contract and recover the asset, paying the business only any excess of the sale proceeds over the outstanding receivable, with the risk that the lease payments already made are largely lost. Both loans and, frequently, leases are moreover backed by personal guarantees from shareholders or directors, which expose their personal assets should the business encounter difficulties.

The view that leasing, unlike a loan, does not affect indebtedness should also be put into perspective. In financial statements prepared under Italian accounting standards, neither the asset nor the residual debt appears on the balance sheet; however, lease contracts are reported to the Bank of Italy's Central Credit Register and the banking system, when assessing creditworthiness, tends to treat future lease payments as financial debt. Choosing leasing does not therefore necessarily improve the company's credit profile.


A numerical example

An example makes it possible to quantify these effects. Consider a machine costing EUR 100,000, with a depreciation rate of 20%, an IRES rate of 24% and an interest rate of 5% for both the loan and the lease, each with a three-year term; the lease provides for an initial lump-sum payment of 10% and a purchase option price of 1%. For simplicity, it is assumed that income is sufficient to absorb the deductions, that interest is fully deductible, that instalments and lease payments are annual and that the asset enters into service in the first financial year, and IRAP is disregarded.

Amounts in euro

Purchase with own funds

3-year bank loan

3-year lease

Initial outlay

100,000

0

10,000

Total cost

100,000

approx. 110,200

approx. 109,200

IRES saved in the first three years

12,000

approx. 14,400

approx. 26,000

Years to deduct the cost

6

6

3, plus the purchase option

In the example, which assumes the same rate, the loan and the lease have a similar overall cost, but the lease makes it possible to recover approximately EUR 26,000 in taxes in the first three financial years, compared with approximately EUR 14,400 for the loan and EUR 12,000 for the purchase with own funds. This is not a permanent saving, since in subsequent financial years the other solutions gradually close the gap, but rather liquidity that remains available to the business at the stage when the investment has not yet fully generated its returns. The advantage of leasing therefore depends on the value the business attributes to that liquidity: if it would otherwise have to resort to more expensive forms of short-term credit, the benefit of not using the price of the asset immediately and of recovering taxes earlier could exceed the net cost of interest, making leasing the most efficient solution, whereas if it has surplus liquidity, a purchase with own funds remains the least expensive solution. Where, as often happens, the lease proves more expensive than the loan, the higher cost should be weighed against the advantage of the accelerated deduction, which is further reduced when the business does not have sufficient income to absorb the deductions or has already reached the limit on the deductibility of interest expense.


Conclusions

Ultimately, the choice depends on the characteristics of the business rather than on the instrument itself. Leasing may prove more advantageous for businesses with stable income and limited debt, as well as for investments in assets subject to rapid obsolescence; a loan makes it possible to acquire ownership of the asset immediately without tying up liquidity; a purchase with own funds remains the most economical solution for those with surplus resources or uncertain income. It is therefore advisable to base the decision on a multi-year simulation of outlays and tax savings that also takes into account the different implicit financing cost of the proposed lease and loan; the Firm remains available to prepare it.

 
 
bottom of page